5 Signs a Will Might Be Contested in Alabama (And What to Do About It)

Losing a family member is hard enough. Discovering that the will doesn't seem right — that something is off, that maybe your loved one wasn't in their right mind when they signed it, or that someone close to them had a suspicious amount of influence — makes an already painful situation even harder.

The good news is that Alabama law allows interested parties to contest a will under certain circumstances. The challenging part is knowing when you have a real case, and when to act.

Here are five signs that a will in Alabama may be worth contesting.

1. The Will Was Changed Suddenly — Especially Near the End of Life

One of the most common red flags is a will that was revised in the weeks or months before a person died, particularly when that change significantly altered who receives what. If your loved one was ill, cognitively impaired, or dependent on others for their care at the time of the change, that's worth taking a close look at.

Alabama courts will examine whether the person signing the will had "testamentary capacity" — meaning they understood what they were doing, what they owned, and who their natural heirs were at the time of signing.

2. A Caregiver, New Romantic Partner, or Recent Acquaintance Is the Primary Beneficiary

When someone who entered a person's life late — and had significant access, control, or influence over them — ends up as a major or sole beneficiary, courts and families rightly pay attention.

This can be a sign of undue influence, which occurs when a third party exerts pressure or manipulation that overrides the testator's free will. Isolation, control of finances, and limiting access to family members are all warning signs.

3. The Will Wasn't Properly Executed

In Alabama, a valid will must be:

• In writing

• Signed by the testator (or by another person in their presence and at their direction)

• Signed by at least two witnesses who were present when the testator signed

If any of these requirements weren't met, the will may be invalid on its face. Witness issues are more common than you'd think — particularly with homemade or online-template wills.

4. There Are Multiple Versions of the Will

When different copies of a will surface — with different beneficiaries, different dates, or different terms — it creates a serious legal question about which one controls. Alabama probate courts determine which document is the valid, final expression of the decedent's wishes, and those disputes can become contentious quickly.

5. You Suspect the Signature Isn't Genuine

Outright forgery is less common than undue influence or capacity issues, but it does happen. If the signature on the will doesn't match other documents, or if witnesses don't recall signing, it may be worth pursuing a forensic analysis.

What to Do If You See These Signs

Time is critical. Alabama has a statute of limitations on will contests — you typically have a limited window after the will is admitted to probate to file a challenge. If you wait too long, you may lose your right to contest entirely.

If something feels wrong, don't assume it will resolve itself. Speak with a probate litigation attorney as early as possible — before the estate is distributed and before your window closes.

Kristin handles will contests and probate litigation throughout Alabama. If you have questions about a family member's estate, we're here to help you understand your options.

205.855.5020 | hello@waterssullivan.com | www.waterssullivan.com